Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Larry Erickson's avatar

I have to push back on one remark in your otherwise informative piece entitled "Newsom and CIF partially cave to Trump."

First, you write that Erin Reed and LGBTQ Nation "falsely" referred to the actions taken as a “limited sports ban” even as you yourself call it a "partial capitulation," which strikes me as a distinction without a difference.

More to the point, you, I won't say falsely but surely incorrectly, say AB Hernandez "is not banned from competing against girls from the girl’s track and field team at her school."

But, as you acknowledge, the plans "create a separate scoring" for cis and trans girls - which means that while Hernandez may be competing *with* other girls, i.e., in the same event on the same field, she is not competing *against* them in any meaningful sense of the word. And that is without even considering the question of interscholastic meets.

Again, the piece was quite informative, but calling a policy that actively restricts the ability of a trans girl to actually compete in sport a “limited ban” is entirely appropriate.

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts